Two Nashville properties can show the same projected annual rent and produce very different results for their owners. Before you spend an afternoon touring, ask the seller to identify the period covered, the source of each number and the operating assumptions behind it. Use this week's curated investment listings to build a shortlist. Inclusion means the property is on the team's research list. Short-term rental permission requires separate verification for the specific address and intended operator.
Rebuild the revenue line from its parts
Start with a blank worksheet and record the unit count, rental period and evidence for each figure. For an occupied long-term rental, request leases, a rent roll and a record of collections, with personal information redacted. For a furnished rental with historical bookings, ask for monthly statements that identify paid stays, cancellations, refunds, blocked dates, cleaning charges and platform deductions. Label projections separately. A deposit into a bank account and the guest's total bill may describe the same stay from opposite ends of the transaction.
Ask whether the property was available for the full year. An owner might have occupied it during the strongest months or taken a unit offline for repairs. Neither situation supports simply multiplying the best month by twelve. Build a month-by-month table and leave missing months blank until you can explain them. If a seller quotes occupancy, ask what counted as an available night in the denominator.
Match the expenses to the income
A projection for a furnished home needs the operating costs of that furnished home. Gather actual bills for utilities, cleaning, supplies, management, recurring maintenance and insurance where available. If a guest-paid cleaning charge appears in revenue, include the corresponding cleaning expense. If the owner performed maintenance or handled bookings personally, get a quote for the work you would hire out. Otherwise two properties can appear equally profitable even though one requires many more hours of your time.
Separate regular operating expenses from financing and major replacements. Set aside a line for cash you expect to spend replacing furniture, appliances or equipment. Show debt payments on their own lines so you can see how a different loan changes your cash needs without changing how the property operates. Keep a dated source next to each input and mark placeholders visibly.
Test a slow period before testing an optimistic one
Suppose, purely for illustration, that a furnished rental earns $200 per paid night. Losing ten booked nights would reduce gross room revenue by $2,000 before any change in expenses. Which costs actually fall when those nights disappear? A per-stay service might decline, while insurance and a fixed management minimum may continue. Repeat the exercise with a repair that interrupts availability. This makes the cash buffer discussion tangible before anyone makes an offer.
Verify the intended use
Identify the governing jurisdiction and request current written information for the parcel, the type of rental and the proposed ownership arrangement. Review applicable association documents as well. Ask what, if anything, a buyer must obtain independently. An existing listing on a booking platform or a prior owner's statements cannot answer those questions for a new purchaser. Keep a second scenario for another independently verified use if that alternative would affect your decision to proceed.
Put a price on missing evidence
Imagine two otherwise similar homes. The first has twelve months of documented collections and invoices. The second offers a projection at the same annual figure, with several expense categories left blank. Give the second home a range for each unresolved item and run the worksheet at both ends. If the high-expense case consumes your available cash, decide which documents you need before spending money on additional inspections or financing applications.
For an owner-managed property, ask for a description of one typical month of work. Include time coordinating repairs, answering inquiries, reconciling payments and visiting the property. Get a management proposal that covers those same tasks and identify any services priced separately. This lets you compare the return from owning the real estate with the compensation you would effectively earn for managing it yourself. Keep both views of the deal so a future change in your availability does not invalidate the entire analysis.
What if the seller provides only a projection?
Treat each figure as an assumption until you find support. Rank the three assumptions that would change your offer the most and investigate those first. Missing evidence is a reason to widen the range of possible outcomes in your worksheet.
What should I bring to the first tour?
Bring the operating worksheet, a list of unresolved use questions, and a short list of physical items that could explain unusually low or high expenses. Andraca Home Group can help request supporting documents and organize a comparison limited to your preferred properties.
See the Latest Listings
Inventory refreshes on the linked page. Browse this week's curated investment listings.